Wesley Plumber, a 36-year-old anxious vocalist, didn’t appear to be your average America’s Got Talent competitor, yet his audition left the audience applauding in awe. In a performance that was full of surprises, Wesley started singing “Take A Chance On Me” by ABBA. But the judges swiftly disqualified him after he struck a depressing note.
An audience member got up and begged the judges to give Wesley another chance after he apologized profusely. In a startling turn of events, the “audience member” then began singing a stirring song about giving Wesley another chance. The camera operator soon followed, then other members of the audience. The surprises didn’t end there, albeit the studio audience was energized.
The band came on stage with Wesley and began a joyful performance of “Take A Chance On Me.” This time, Wesley hit every note flawlessly, and as the show progressed, a large audience choir and the UCLA marching band overwhelmed the studio, bringing brass instruments and lively energy to the air. Everyone in the audience sprang up, cheering and clapping, enthralled by the festive mood.
Wesley said at the conclusion of the jaw-dropping performance that Improv Everywhere, a performance art collective from New York City famous for viral stunts like Grocery Store Musical and their Grand Central freeze, was responsible for the entire thing.
The task of determining Wesley’s destiny fell to the judges. With an enthusiastic “yes” and a description of the performance as “fun and light-hearted,” Heidi Klum was utterly delighted. Although Sofía Vergara enjoyed the spectacle, she wasn’t convinced enough to agree, saying there wasn’t enough surprise in the reveal.
However, Simon Cowell vehemently defended the act, saying, “I was truly surprised, and the whole point was to surprise us.” It simply kept growing, and I adored it. Applause from the audience echoed Cowell and Klum’s enthusiastic responses.
Improv Everywhere Full Performance | America’s Got Talent 2023 Auditions Week 9 – YouTube
Howie Mandel followed, but he wasn’t impressed. He questioned what shocks they could offer next and criticized the performance as “great for a party gag” but inappropriate for the competition. He became the night’s “villain” after receiving jeers from the audience and even host Terry Crews’ disapproval for his firm no vote.
Despite receiving negative evaluations, Wesley’s audition turned into a joyful and creative moment. The performance demonstrated the power of unexpected surprises and made a lasting effect on both the audience and spectators at home, despite the judges’ divided votes.
Wesley Plumber, a 36-year-old anxious vocalist, didn’t appear to be your average America’s Got Talent competitor, yet his audition left the audience applauding in awe. In a performance that was full of surprises, Wesley started singing “Take A Chance On Me” by ABBA. But the judges swiftly disqualified him after he struck a depressing note.
An audience member got up and begged the judges to give Wesley another chance after he apologized profusely. In a startling turn of events, the “audience member” then began singing a stirring song about giving Wesley another chance. The camera operator soon followed, then other members of the audience. The surprises didn’t end there, albeit the studio audience was energized.
The band came on stage with Wesley and began a joyful performance of “Take A Chance On Me.” This time, Wesley hit every note flawlessly, and as the show progressed, a large audience choir and the UCLA marching band overwhelmed the studio, bringing brass instruments and lively energy to the air. Everyone in the audience sprang up, cheering and clapping, enthralled by the festive mood.
Wesley said at the conclusion of the jaw-dropping performance that Improv Everywhere, a performance art collective from New York City famous for viral stunts like Grocery Store Musical and their Grand Central freeze, was responsible for the entire thing.
The task of determining Wesley’s destiny fell to the judges. With an enthusiastic “yes” and a description of the performance as “fun and light-hearted,” Heidi Klum was utterly delighted. Although Sofía Vergara enjoyed the spectacle, she wasn’t convinced enough to agree, saying there wasn’t enough surprise in the reveal.
However, Simon Cowell vehemently defended the act, saying, “I was truly surprised, and the whole point was to surprise us.” It simply kept growing, and I adored it. Applause from the audience echoed Cowell and Klum’s enthusiastic responses.

Howie Mandel followed, but he wasn’t impressed. He questioned what shocks they could offer next and criticized the performance as “great for a party gag” but inappropriate for the competition. He became the night’s “villain” after receiving jeers from the audience and even host Terry Crews’ disapproval for his firm no vote.
Despite receiving negative evaluations, Wesley’s audition turned into a joyful and creative moment. The performance demonstrated the power of unexpected surprises and made a lasting effect on both the audience and spectators at home, despite the judges’ divided votes.
